What does it actually mean to say that God’s love is “beyond our deserving”?

For over 400 Sundays, Rev. Tim has recited the same closing benediction that contains the words, “the love of Jesus Christ which is beyond our deserving.” While it’s a comforting thought, it also begs a slightly awkward question: why do we assume we’re undeserving in the first place? He points the finger at heavy-duty historical baggage in Reformed Protestantism—concepts such as “worm theology” and penal substitutionary atonement—which taught generations of believers to view themselves as wrecks who need to be rescued from divine wrath. But Rev. Tim argues that grace isn’t a cosmic merit badge or a transactional debt to be paid. It’s pure, unearned love.

To show what that actually looks like on the ground, he shared a story from Jesuit priest Greg Boyle, the man behind Homeboy Industries in Los Angeles. Back when Boyle was a young, struggling missionary up in the mountains of Bolivia, he barely spoke the local language. He tanked a Sunday Mass, botched the prayers, and sat alone on the mountainside feeling like the worst priest on earth. As he sat there wallowing in self-pity, an old farmer in tattered clothes walked up, reached into his coat pocket, pulled out a handful of rose petals, and dropped them over Boyle’s head, over and over again, until a pile of petals covered him. That’s the whole point: grace isn’t something we work for or earn—it’s a steady stream of petals falling on us, even when we feel like a total mess.

Bible Verse: Ephesians 2:1-10 / Image Credit: Benediction by Daniel Chester French (1922)